13-10-2014, 03:01
bu da http://chesscafe.com/text/geurt137.pdf
Geurt Gijssen'e 2009'da sorulan soru ve benzer bir durumda bir oyuncuyu suçlamak için bir sebep görmediğini yazıyor.özet geçersem iki oyuncununda süresi az. 15 dk'ya 5 dk. süresi çok olan sporcunun hamle yapıyor,az olan sporcuda nasılsa basacak deyip hızlıca hamle yapıyor ,fakat süresi çok olan sporcu gene hızlıca hamlesini yapıyor. tersten ama benzer
Question 2 We had a seminar on the FIDE Laws of Chess in which I
received an interesting question. Suppose in a standard time control game
(90 min + 30 sec), Player A was in time trouble with less than one
minute, while Player B had more than 15 minutes. Player B captured a
piece, and Player A, in a hurry, without waiting for Player B to press the
clock, recaptured the piece immediately, with the expectation that Player
B would press his clock straightaway. However, in order to keep Player A
under time pressure, Player B declines to press the clock until he makes
another move, thereby sacrificing his 30 second increment for his
opponent’s. I did not find that this violates any article in the FIDE Laws
of Chess. However, this is not a good sportsmanship for any chess player.
Am I missing something? Is it compulsory for players to press their own
clocks or not? Best regards, Teerapong Tovirat (Thailand)
Answer 2 There is nothing in the Laws of Chess that states a player must
immediately press his clock after he has made his move. This means that
Player B did not violate any Article of the Laws of Chess. However, how
could we know that it was Player B’s intention to keep Player A under
pressure? Perhaps he simply forgot to press his clock. I would also like to
mention that as long Player B’s clock is running, Player A has some extra
time to calculate his next move. I do not see any reason to blame Player B
for his behavior.
Geurt Gijssen'e 2009'da sorulan soru ve benzer bir durumda bir oyuncuyu suçlamak için bir sebep görmediğini yazıyor.özet geçersem iki oyuncununda süresi az. 15 dk'ya 5 dk. süresi çok olan sporcunun hamle yapıyor,az olan sporcuda nasılsa basacak deyip hızlıca hamle yapıyor ,fakat süresi çok olan sporcu gene hızlıca hamlesini yapıyor. tersten ama benzer
Question 2 We had a seminar on the FIDE Laws of Chess in which I
received an interesting question. Suppose in a standard time control game
(90 min + 30 sec), Player A was in time trouble with less than one
minute, while Player B had more than 15 minutes. Player B captured a
piece, and Player A, in a hurry, without waiting for Player B to press the
clock, recaptured the piece immediately, with the expectation that Player
B would press his clock straightaway. However, in order to keep Player A
under time pressure, Player B declines to press the clock until he makes
another move, thereby sacrificing his 30 second increment for his
opponent’s. I did not find that this violates any article in the FIDE Laws
of Chess. However, this is not a good sportsmanship for any chess player.
Am I missing something? Is it compulsory for players to press their own
clocks or not? Best regards, Teerapong Tovirat (Thailand)
Answer 2 There is nothing in the Laws of Chess that states a player must
immediately press his clock after he has made his move. This means that
Player B did not violate any Article of the Laws of Chess. However, how
could we know that it was Player B’s intention to keep Player A under
pressure? Perhaps he simply forgot to press his clock. I would also like to
mention that as long Player B’s clock is running, Player A has some extra
time to calculate his next move. I do not see any reason to blame Player B
for his behavior.